This article is the second instalment of Harutyun Marutyan’s "The Karabakh Movement or What was Happening in Soviet Armenia 30 Years Ago." 

In 1989, social and political upheavals shook one Eastern European country after another, something historians would later characterize as “Eastern European Revolutions” or simply the “Revolutions of 1989.” The Berlin Wall, in the heart of Europe, which had symbolized the dividing line between the “democratic” West and the “communist” East, came down. With this, the socialist camp disintegrated; within two years the Soviet Empire disappeared from the world map; the ghost of communism, roaming in Europe from the times of Marx and Engels was confined to the pages of history and merely became the subject of study. A year before these developments, a powerful democratic movement began in the smallest of the Soviet Republics, in Soviet Armenia. In academic literature, with a few exceptions, it is considered only within the context of what was seen as an “ethno-territorial” conflict, an Armenian-Azerbaijani one. In my opinion, what took place in Armenia as part of the Karabakh Movement, was the first of the Eastern European revolutions and as such, played a considerable role in the democratization of Soviet society, had a substantial part in the deconstruction of the Soviet Union and consequently the elimination of the threat of communism. As the first, it was not regarded or perceived as a revolution, and as such, remained obscure in academic circles, whereas the formulations of the “unrecognized revolution” can shed new light on the study and evaluation of democracies that emerged in Eastern Europe in the late 20th century.

 

One of the distinctive characteristics of the Karabakh Movement was that in two and a half years, it drastically changed how the Soviet value system was perceived. The visual and verbal manifestation of this was evident through the transformation of the language and texts of the posters and signs used during the Movement.

In general, images and slogans are among the most palpable expressions of national identity, and as a rule, they appear during times of crises and accompany revolutions, mass national gatherings, radical changes in the life of a county; sometimes alongside processes that can last years. Often, as direct indicators of the the popular mood, or sometimes having been created by political forces, signs contain an enormous wealth of information about the era allowing a clearer understanding of the times. These are unique knots of identity where many different threads are pulled together and concentrated. Unraveling the unique microcosms of those knots allows one to view macrocosmic phenomena. Posters, as visual “testimonials” of social processes, usually immediately echo the changes of a situation, making it easy to follow the steps of social developments through posters and through an analysis of their contextual changes to follow the transformations of political orientation and identity. In this regard, the Karabakh Movement offers a large and rich field of study.  

What is distinctive about the posters created during the Karabakh Movement is that an overwhelming majority of them represented not so much the agendas of certain parties or political currents but the concerns, moods, wishes and evaluations of people regarding certain developments. If during the Soviet era posters carried the ideological stamp of the ruling party and were strictly regulated and ruled out any divergence, the posters of the Movement incorporated a wide variety of genres, had contextual diversity and ideologically stemmed from a nationalistic as well as Soviet construct. In other words, the visualizations were direct indicators of the public’s liberated mindset.

They were often also manifestations of archetypical national thought. At the beginning of the Movement, this was explained by the fact that the verbal information - political speeches delivered during the protests, the discussions - were not supplemented with a visual presentations, because in their programs and reports, the Soviet television and press did not fully reflect the situation and in their evaluations of the unfolding events, an intentional bias was noticeable.

Under these circumstances and aside from being the visual representation of the Movement’s struggle, the posters also took on the function of a free press, greatly contributing towards the political education of the masses and a qualitative change of identity.  During the years of the Karabakh Movement, in person-authorities-society-state relations, the posters were those intermediaries and unique tools through which the mindset of people and society were transferred including also their appeals to the ruling authorities and the evaluations given to them.

The posters were addressed not only to the ruling authorities, but also to the Armenian people, the Hayastantsis, the Azerbaijanis, all the citizens of the large Soviet state, the world - in other words to everyone who was interested in issues concerning Armenians. The posters were a unique monologue of the people, with the hope of transforming it into a dialogue. In this way, they were equal to dozens if not hundreds of interviews, polls...by analyzing the texts of the posters it was clear how the process of expelling Homo Sovieticus from inside hundreds of thousands of people was taking place.

Let's try to illustrate the above with a few examples. Radical changes in attitudes took place:

  • Concerning the central media outlets of the USSR

  • Concerning the USSR Constitution

  • Concerning the Central Committee of the Soviet Union (ԽՄԿԿ)

  • Concerning the Soviet judiciary

  • Armenians’ centuries-old faith in the Russian people and the Russian soldier as a savior was shattered

  • The need to combat Russian cultural assimilation was realized

  • It was understood that ideology of the international, unbroken friendship of the people of USSR was hollow

  • The value of the Armenian peoples’ unity was realized

  • The belief in working independently was understood and grew exponentially 

In other words, ideas conditioned by external and internal factors, being born at the bottom, matured and gradually encompassed nationwide involvement.

Of the national-democratic movements and revolutions in the former territories of the USSR, the Armenian Revolution was the first. Confronted with opposition from the state apparatus, many things were developing autonomously in Armenia, however, within the framework of existing laws. It is for this reason that I don’t rule out that the knowledge gained from researching the Armenian Revolution, can and does propose new, perhaps nuanced factors in the study of contemporary revolutions.

118 glasnost as toilet paper xiii 15

As a rule, every new phenomenon has its uniqueness, knowledge of which can provide new clarifications while studying events that proceed it. The Karabakh Movement or the ‘unrecognized’ Armenian Revolution until today, has not been considered a research area in the contemporary theory of revolutions neither in Armenia or elsewhere; a comparative analysis of similar events that took place in the USSR or Eastern Europe has not been addressed. This is one of the issues confronting Armenian social scientists.

I reserve the right to express the opinion that the Karabakh Movement was an indicator of how the small Armenian nation, at the end of the 20th century rose up against the most powerful Soviet Empire and won, not with power, but with democratic national values fomenting such a revolutionary wave that it led to the fall of the Berlin Wall and sent the fear of communism into the pages of history.

 

All images are from H. Marutyan's personal archive or his book, “Iconography of Armenian Identity-Volume 1: The Memory of Genocide and the Karabakh Movement.”   

Concerning Armenians’  faith in the Russian people and the Russian soldier as a savior. 

thumb img 6063 1024
Moscow-Yerevan, 1988.
27534994 10159890032035285 1236183454 o copy
Yerevan, Swan Lake, "The dance of the little swans." 
30716036 10160235650035285 5679761702527172608 n
"The deadly indifference of the guardian angel."  
30727099 10160235811950285 8793405188724490240 n
"But these are our children..." A reference to Gorbachev's response to a Soviet soldier being injured during clashes in Yerevan. 
30704371 10160235649695285 7016908862858985472 n
Czechoslovakia, Poland, Afghanistan.
27335186 10159870107965285 1828717818 o
"Friendship and brotherhood of the USSR nations."  
30716075 10160235649650285 3819473042912837632 n
"The strong center of the strong republic."  
photo 41

Concerning the USSR Constitution and Gorbachev's Glasnost and Perestroika. 

83 6154a nov4 1989
27393919 10159870107110285 525335927 o
The sleeves read, "Democracy, Perestroika, Glasnost," the Rubic's cube reads, "Artsakh." 
79a 6150a nov4 1989
xiii 14 november 4 5 1989 hhsh congress
"Party and nation are one." The word "Nation" is designed to be hanging from the letters of the word "Party."
ii 12 july 20 august 3 crop
"The red cow will not change her skin."  
30725255 10160235650730285 1894768584052178944 n
The Constitution.  
27335351 10159870107700285 1121377831 o copy
A political caricature depicting Gorbachev. On the ballon is written "Perestroika;" the suitcase reads, "Democracy, Glasnost." 
30712185 10160235652020285 7455338862441660416 n
"Did not hear, did not see, did not speak," Gobachev - 1915: Genocide, 1988: Sugait, 1989: Blockade. 
iii 21 october 13 1988
The word Constitution in Russian that is brought down to a single letter "я" meaning "I".  
xiii 16 november 4 5 1989 hhsh congress
Lenin's national policy: Free BLEEDING of nations.  
1989 hhsh nov 4 5
Glasnost. 

Concerning the central media outlets of the USSR. 

tv vremya nazad iii 23
In reference to the opening credits, "Time Forward" of main TV news program Vremyan (Time), but changed to read, "Time backward."
30709065 10160236112780285 2203508781956988928 n
A scarecrow made of diffrent newspapers - Pravda, Izvestya, Communist.  
27485143 10159890112595285 110116605 o copy copy
The word "Presssss" pressed between two telephones and a copy of the Pravda newspaper.   

Concerning the Soviet judiciary. 

30741945 10160235651805285 7148383897758203904 n

Concenrning the environment.  

30725066 10160235651185285 1414415640621481984 n
"Nairit is Moscow's nitrogen bomb." 
30724157 10160235651670285 8127365244126232576 n
Nairit.  
30707176 10160235651060285 5405732030149296128 n
"Nairit: Picket to the end."  

Others.  

29512689 10160137719375285 3186310175317295104 o
27335544 10159867157790285 1234033002 o
ii 11 july 20 august 3 1988
iii 11 october 13 1988
The arrows read: "Unity," "We Demand," "Strike."
ii 15 july 20 august 3 1988
xiii 1 november 4 5 1989 hhsh congress
A crossword puzzle with the names of Stalin’s victims. 

EVN Report wishes to thank the Friedrich Ebert Stiftung (FES) for their cooperation and support.    


 Portraits of Memory - Aram Manukyan  

 Portraits of Memory - Harutyun Marutyan 

Velvet Revolution: The Moments In-Between

In 2018, the Armenian people were swept up in a nationwide movement that would come to be known as the Velvet Revolution. Photojournalist Eric Grigorian took thousands of photos, documenting and capturing images of ordinary people who came together to achieve the extraordinary. Through his own words, Grigorian tells the story of the revolution and the moments in-between.

------------------------------

Portraits of Memory: Gyumri

 

This year marks not only the 30th anniversary of the earthquake, but also the 30th anniversary of the start of the Karabakh Movement. Before the Velvet Revolution, EVN Report traveled to Gyumri to talk to the people there about their memories, concerns and dreams for the future. These are the voices of the participants of the 1988 Movement from Gyumri.

 

 

-------------------------------

Introspective Armenia: Portraits of Memory

Dedicated to the 30th Anniversary of the Karabakh Movement

 

The 1988 Karabakh Movement brought about a period of intense and sweeping changes and the people of Armenia were leading the charge. 

 

 

-----------------------------------------

Ինտրոսպեկտիվ Հայաստան. Հիշողության դիմանկարներ

Նվիրվում է Ղարաբաղյան շարժման 30-ամյակին

1988-ին սկասած Ղարաբաղյան Շարժումը ինտենսիվ և վիթխարի փոփոխությունների ժամանակաշրջան էր, որն առաջնորդում էր հայ ժողովուրդը: 

 

When we launched EVN Report on March 16, 2017 in Yerevan, our mission was to be the first reader-supported Armenian publication. But we had to prove to you, our reader, what we were made of. So, for the past year we have written extensively and critically about issues impacting our lives in Armenia and the Diaspora. Our goal was to elevate the conversation, to bring meaning and context to our own unique digital town square. We have also been a platform where the world can take a peek inside our complexities, hardships, accomplishments and victories. If you read something that meant something on EVN Report, then we are asking you to support us so that we maintain our independence and are accountable to you.

Please visit our Support Us page to learn more:https://www.evnreport.com/donate


All rights reserved by EVN Report
Developed by Gugas Team